The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 
GG-1000x50

[updated] This is important: Joe Morgan, Jon Miller no longer the voices of ESPN's Sunday Night Baseball

 

Two years after Ken Tremendous shut down the site dedicated to the cause, the Times reports that ESPN has fired Joe Morgan. Or "declined to renew [his] contract," according to the Times. Jon Miller's destination is still unclear, though the network has decided to move on from the team for the Sunday night baseball broadcasts.

I acknowledge that both men have their fans, but ultimately this is good news for baseball fans.  Miller has a classic voice, sure, but his tone could occasionally sound condescending, as though he was describing the game to a kindergartener. As for Morgan: where do you want to start? He did know the game, and he would provide the occasional strong insight, but all of that was outweighed by his stubborn, "flat-earth society"-esque approach to advanced metrics and the general emphasis on on-base percentage and power (bolstered by an almost pathological hatred of Billy Beane and computers) throughout baseball (and yes, this would be the same approach that won Theo Epstein and Bill James two World Series rings with the Red Sox). Even though, ironically, he was exactly that type of player during his career - he was one of the best second basemen of all time, no joke. But that's irrelevant. Even if you don't account for the stats issue, or his seeming lack of awareness of what was happening in the baseball games he wasn't assigned to broadcast, he is presently employed by the Cincinnati Reds (which led to him, among other things, showering with the team recently), which, I would think, would constitute a conflict of interest. Although I guess Don Orsillo is employed by the Red Sox (via NESN), and he does national games, so maybe this is a grayer area than I realize.

Either way, I'll take Orel Hershiser, who actually comes off as fairly thoughtful in the booth, over Morgan any day.

UPDATE: Larry Granillo of Wezen-Ball has an interesting take on this over at Awful Announcing. Short version: Morgan and Miller weren't great, but the real problem with Sunday Night Baseball was their tendency to seek out a storyline about the game before the game even starts and then stick to that angle during the game regardless of what was actually happening. He's right, of course, and anyone who's ever watched Joe Buck and Tim McCarver (and incidentally, McCarver is a much worse broadcaster than Morgan in every way possible) on Fox will tell you that this is not an ESPN-only problm - nor, for that matter is it exclusive to baseball; how much will viewers hear about the careers of Greg Oden and Kevin Durant during this Friday's Blazers-Thunder game on ESPN? 

Granillo believes this is unlikely to change with the switchover to Hershiser and Henry Schulman (if, indeed, that is the team ESPN winds up going with), and he's probably right. None of this invalidates the complaints about Morgan in my view, and I don't think Granillo is saying the guy should be staying or anything like that, only that Morgan is symptom rather than cause.

Ultimately, I think that both the networks and fans alike need to have the larger conversation about the proper role of the play-by-play and color commentators during the broadcast of a sporting event, as that (along with the officiating of the game) seems to be what people complain about the most often when watching sports on television. My sense is that most people want broadcasters to stay out of the game's way and focus on the action on the field, rink, court, or pitch, which is something networks have failed to grasp lately. I do think there is value in an ex-player pointing out something that most of us fans - even those of us who watch several dozen games a year - wouldn't notice, and I would guess that somewhere along the line, some producer told an ex-player to make that the focus of his commentary. At some point, presumably, that became the hustle-fetish we see when we watch nowadays, where people only discuss those "little things" on the air, and a guy like David Eckstein gets praised more frequently than a guy like Alex Rodriguez. I think the national broadcasts also tend to underestimate how much their audiences are watching the sport in question on a regular basis - especially nowadays when it's so much easier to follow not just one team but several. But maybe I'm wrong about that. I don't know if it's possible to satisfy both casual and diehards on the same broadcast. I would love to see someone try, though.

Filed Under: ,
| More

1 Comments

  • Michael Marotta said:

    I like the consistency Joe Morgan has shown in this post he wrote. But no way could it beat the 1975 Reds. Sorry.

    November 9, 2010 12:17 PM

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
ADVERTISEMENT
Filed Under: ,
Related Articles

[updated] This is important: Joe Morgan, Jon Miller no longer the voices of ESPN's Sunday Night Baseball
Boston Phoenix
[updated] This is important: Joe Morgan, Jon Miller no longer the voices of ESPN's Sunday Night Baseball
Published 11/8/2010 by Ryan Stewart
 Two years after Ken Tremendous shut down the site dedicated to the cause, the Times reports that ESPN has fired Joe Morgan. Or "declined to...

102910_BJFF_list
Boston Phoenix
Independence and assimilation at the 2010 Boston Jewish Film Festival
Published 10/29/2010 by PETER KEOUGH
Team efforts

more by Ryan Stewart
LO500 Featured Battle: Diablo II vs. Baldur's Gate II | November 12, 2010
The L.A. Noire trailer looks pretty good | November 11, 2010
[updated] Viacom selling Harmonix | November 11, 2010
[updated] This is important: Joe Morgan, Jon Miller no longer the voices of ESPN's Sunday Night Baseball | November 08, 2010
Tonight: Conan O'Brien returns to television | November 08, 2010

 See all articles by: Ryan Stewart

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
[weezer review] Night 1: Feeling "Blue" with Rivers Cuomo - came here to read a review of a fucking show and had to sift through 4 opening paragraphs of the reviewer's...

By J on 12-20-2010 in On The Download

Middle East shifts to digital promotion, discourages bands posting printed flyers - "like a drunken bassist handing out his digits at last call." Hey! Was that shot at me! Because...

By P. Nick Curran on 12-16-2010 in On The Download

Middle East shifts to digital promotion, discourages bands posting printed flyers - Like anything in life, with change comes opportunity. While I'll miss some of the beautiful poster...

By Jesse James on 12-16-2010 in On The Download

NYC Guerrilla Literary Reading - I was following this. The Huffington Post ran a great story on it today - thephoenix.com/.../nyc-guerrilla...

By Liam Leadbelly on 12-16-2010 in PageViews

'No Fun' on Harvard Avenue: The Scrooges @ O'Brien's & the Horror Business closing sale - Free link for the Mellow Bravo record mentioned above. rcpt.yousendit.com/.../f249bda672c4d27782bc23c1388c587b

By KEITH PIERCE on 12-16-2010 in On The Download

Latest Comments from Phlog
Most Viewed
Liveblogging Franzen on Oprah
NYC Guerrilla Literary Reading
Ticket on-sale alert: the Pogues, Snoop Dogg, and Robyn
[mp3] Stereo Telescope give thanks with holiday single "Draw Me A Sky"
MP3 Of The Week: Dirty Bombs, ‘In Every City’
WFNX Boston Accents playlist 11.28.10: 2010 Boston Music Awards edition
[live video & review] Bear In Heaven and Twin Shadow @ the Middle East
Most Viewed from Phlog
Search Blogs
 
Phlog Archives
Wednesday, December 22, 2010  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
thePhoenix.com
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2010 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group