The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 
Best2011Vote-1000x50

83rd Oscar post mortem

 

The opening Best Picture montage bit in the 83rd Oscars Broadcast, satirically visiting each Best Picture nominee within an "Inception" framework, almost had me thinking that they'd pull it off, with James Franco and Anne Hathaway filling the roles of genial, energetic, funny,  hip hosts without the squirmy mordant edge of Ricky Gervais. But then right away some problems emerged.


First of, all the recollection that a variation on the same idea was done by Billy Crystal to much better, classically hilarious effect back in 1997. It served as a reminder of how much his hosting talents -- perhaps the best thing he's done in his career -- are missed.  This reminder was not helped by Crystal's appearance on the show a little later. Though, perhaps not to rub it in, he was not funny.

The second problem was casting Alec Baldwin in the bit. Not that he wasn't good -- his dry humor was perfect for this kind of thing. But, once again, it only served to point up how superior his co-hosting stint with Steve Martin last year was to the incoherent, tedious farrago about to unfold.

If this Oscar broadcast had any distinguishing features, it was its brevity and weirdness. At around three and a half hours, it was on the shorter end of the spectrum, but time is relative to quality and so it seemed one of the longest since Rob Lowe sang and danced with Snow White in 1989 (hey, at least they had more chemistry than James and Anne). And though that number was pretty weird, it was no weirder than Kirk Douglas at 94 hitting on Anne Hathaway and Melissa Leo, or Bob Hope appearing through the magic of hologram technology to loom over the proceedings like a black-and-white Wizard of Oz -- a reminder that, back in the day, he wasn't very funny either.

 

In a sense, the broadcast had the merit of mirroring the winners. With "The King's Speech" and "Inception" both taking the most Oscars with four awards, the Academy shows a desperate, schizoid impulse to placate the old-timers (note this article in the "New York Times" about the upsurge in Boomer moviegoers) and get with the kids. The sad thing is that instead they demonstrate that they are not only incapable of tapping into a younger, irreverent sensibility but also clueless when it comes to exploiting their own rich if meretricious heritage.

That is why "True Grit,"  one of the best films of the year and certainly better than "The King's Speech" and "Inception," won nothing. It (and "The Social Network," too, when you come right down to it)  is the perfect fusion of one of the most venerable of genres with cutting edge auteurs. It's the future of Hollywood, if they ever recognize it.


| More

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Articles

RIIFF-Oscar-Night_list
Boston Phoenix
Photos: The RIIFF Oscar Night at Veteran's Memorial Auditorium
Published 3/4/2011 by CAROLYN BUBEL
Oscar Night | February 27, 2011

The Waggling and the Pfisting: Laser Orgy reviews last night’s Oscars live chat
Boston Phoenix
The Waggling and the Pfisting: Laser Orgy reviews last night’s Oscars live chat
Published 2/28/2011 by Alec Ernest
 By Derek Kouyoumjian. Click here for more photos from the Brattle's Oscars party.When you're broadcasting a universally smug, circle-pat-on-the-back session like the Academy Awards to...

more by Peter Keough
See these films: the New Latin American Cinema series at the MFA | March 02, 2011
83rd Oscar post mortem | February 28, 2011
See these films: "Yilmaz Güney: From 'Ugly King' to Poet of Despair" series at the HFA | February 25, 2011
See this film: The Kids Are All Right at the Brattle | February 25, 2011
Speech impediments? | February 25, 2011

 See all articles by: Peter Keough

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
Why we need to hold the Radical Right responsible for the Arizona bloodshed - Yes, and every time a woman is raped Playboy is to blame. Bludgeon away--while your generalizations are...

By quadmax on 02-27-2011 in Phlog

Charlestown Pharma-Bandit Flick "Oxy Morons" Back For Another Theater Run - ya well doesnt look like their manin up!! SO johnny keep doing what ur doing bro!!

By SJB243 on 02-27-2011 in Phlog

Charlestown Pharma-Bandit Flick "Oxy Morons" Back For Another Theater Run - I rent so much space in their head cuz they follow more then the feds did when I was a dirt bal lol....

By the johnny hickey on 02-26-2011 in Phlog

Charlestown Pharma-Bandit Flick "Oxy Morons" Back For Another Theater Run - I rent so much space in their head cuz they follow more then the feds did when I was a dirt bal lol....

By the johnny hickey on 02-26-2011 in Phlog

Charlestown Pharma-Bandit Flick "Oxy Morons" Back For Another Theater Run - So just so you all know this johnny hickey loud and proud. The 308 boyz stands for a federal prison label...

By the johnny hickey on 02-26-2011 in Phlog

Latest Comments from Outside The Frame
Most Viewed
3rd Annual Boston Book Festival Announced
Ticket on-sale alert: NKOTBSB, Fleet Foxes, Chris Cornell, Raveonettes, Ellie Goulding, Rusko, and more
Necessary shelter: Crosby and Emmet record month-long Covers Project
New Cars album gets title, street date
MP3 of the Week: Thick Shakes "Go Back To New York"
[Q&A] Robyn on the "reinvention" myth, playing to a pop audience, and rediscovering Euro-dance
[make ur own lazer school photo] The Appreciation Post's "Totally Awesome '90s Party"
Most Viewed from Outside The Frame
Search Blogs
 
Outside The Frame Archives
Wednesday, March 02, 2011  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
thePhoenix.com
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2011 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group