The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
CD Reviews  |  Classical  |  Live Reviews  |  Music Features  |  New England Music News

Scrutiny of the bounty

Was 2008 the best year ever for local music releases?
By SAM PFEIFLE  |  December 23, 2008

TOP ALBUM: Ray LaMontagne's Gossip in the Grain.

I'm an enthusiastic guy, and maybe prone to hyperbole from time to time, but it's hard to argue that 2008 wasn't an all-time banner year for music created here in the Portland area. While the live scene continues to rebound, buoyed by the emergence of One Longfellow, the Meg Perry Center, and the Empire, particularly, along with a new handful of alternative venues where all manner of indie stuff goes down, it still cannot possibly hang with the album and EP releases. And there's the continuing issue of cover bands creeping into what was solely original music's territory.

Read: And then some... By Christopher Gray.

Maybe next year when the Port City Music Hall gets its sea legs, and (fingers crossed, rumors are flying) the State Theatre reopens, things will even up between the digital and live scenes. Getting some more out-of-town blood flowing through our fair city can only serve to excite live music fans in general and make them hunger for more great shows.

But first, the numbers: I've been tracking full-length releases by Portland-area bands and solo artists since 2004, and this year saw at least a 33 percent jump over least year's previous high of 61. By my count, there were no fewer than 81 full-length albums released locally, with another 19 EPs (there were 52 full-lengths in 2004, just 28 in 2005 — what now looks like the nadir for local music, and 46 in 2006).

Of course, my standards have changed a little. Where once I didn't count CD-Rs and digital-only releases, this year I've decided to make the tent bigger. Especially the founding of Milled Pavement's Emben label and the increasing quality of the indie CD-Rs has changed the local landscape for music consumption significantly. None of these kinds of releases cracked my top 20 albums for 2008, but many of them were in the next 10 and you'll see some of them profiled in Chris Gray's accompanying article about some of the year's best hidden gems. I've continued to exclude compilations and live albums.

As always for this list, albums are ranked by originality, musicianship, how long something from the disc lasts in my head, the number of plays they got on the iPod, and whether they contain a truly outstanding song. I've also this year integrated some consideration for production value and the quality of the listening experience. I've decided that has to count for something.

So, here's the list. It was a agonizing process of elimination to get to this point. But first some caveats: I'm not counting the new Sparks the Rescue album as a 2008 disc because I think it will get a new and wider release in 2009 and would like to consider it there. Similarly, while I'd love to consider Pinkwood 2, Seekonk only released a limited 100-print run of it on LP, and it just seems unfair to tease people with what they might someday hear. Finally, people may quibble with Ray LaMontagne's localness, but I don't care. He's ours, and I want to keep it that way.

Top 20 Albums of 2008

1_Ray LaMontagne, Gossip in the Grain

2_Gypsy Tailwind, Halo Sessions

3_Jerks of Grass, Come on Home

4_Baltic Sea, Through Scenic Heights and Days Regrets

5_Phantom Buffalo, Take to the Trees

6_Darien Brahms, Number 4

7_Daro, Self-titled

8_Dominic and the Lucid, Season of the Sun

9_Micah Blue Smaldone, The Red River

10_Conifer, Crown Fire

11_Dead End Armory, Hope You're Good

12_Steve Grover, Between Now and After

13_Chriss Sutherland, Me in a "Field"

14_Ogre, Plague of the Planet

15_The Pete Kilpatrick Band, Hope in Our Hearts

16_Spose, Preposterously Dank

17_As Fast As, Destroy the Plastique Man

18_Roy Davis and the Dregs, Deadweight

19_Samuel James, Songs Famed for Sorrow and Joy

20_Dead Season, When Everything's Lost

TOP EP: The Bay State's Let's Turn This City On

Best EPs
And, of course, the year's five best EPs (and, for the first year, I could have been happy running a top 10 EPs):

1_The Bay State, Let's Turn This City On

2_The Cambiata, To Heal

3_Sidecar Radio, Wave Principle

4_Travis Kline, More Time

5_Pinsky, Two for the Road

Related: New England Music News: March 6, 2009, Gossip=Truth, The boy with no name, More more >
  Topics: Music Features , Baltic Sea, Darien Brahms, DARO,  More more >
  • Share:
  • RSS feed Rss
  • Email this article to a friend Email
  • Print this article Print
Re: Scrutiny of the bounty
What no Metal Feathers?  The Bay State?  They sucked when they were called yellowcard.
By brian snake on 12/24/2008 at 9:23:28
Re: Scrutiny of the bounty
No Loverless and Sparks the Rescue and inclusion of the grossly overrated Dead Season makes this list akin to one of those VH-1 lists...
By spitcup on 12/25/2008 at 4:14:52
Re: Scrutiny of the bounty
By Kelly22 on 12/29/2008 at 11:32:32
Re: Scrutiny of the bounty
By Kelly22 on 12/29/2008 at 11:33:53
Re: Scrutiny of the bounty
Spitcup: It says right in the opener that Sparks was not considered for 2008.
By Car in Lincolnville on 01/03/2009 at 12:00:38

Share this entry with Delicious

 See all articles by: SAM PFEIFLE

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2009 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group