The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Big Hurt  |  CD Reviews  |  Classical  |  Jazz  |  Live Reviews  |  Music Features

The '90s spawn of gothic rock

Mall bats
By MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER  |  October 26, 2011

GOTH OFFSPRING My Chemical Romance were straight goth for the emo set.

In recent years, the long arm of goth has rested on many a musical shoulder. And as with most things influential, sometimes this has been a good thing, and other times goth has simply offered another poor excuse for the existence of Hot Topic. Either way, many mainstream rock acts have appropriated the look and themes of the genre and brought along its fans — people who normally wouldn't be caught undead at a party like Ceremony.

Trent Reznor has never been afraid to fly his goth flag, weaving it in and out of his music, most notably on the Nine Inch Nails debut, Pretty Hate Machine. When The Crow came out in 1994, his cover of Joy Division's "Dead Souls" became synonymous with the film. And a joint tour five years ago with Bauhaus was a wet dream for many goth traditionalists.

Reznor's progeny, Marilyn Manson, grew directly out of goth. His was music for the displaced, the loners, kids who understood precisely why Columbine happened. Fans gravitated to his darkness — but it was all a facile contrivance. Manson envisioned himself as more of a David Bowie or Alice Cooper for the new day, frequently changing looks and personae. A few years ago, with mainstream popularity waning, he returned to goth — and its look. But it was one shape-shift too many for the goth faithful — the love was not reciprocated.

Type O Negative didn't set out to become goth and generally aren't considered more than a morbid metal band, but the vast majority of their compositions were about loneliness, loss, and death. With their unwavering despair, tracks like "Die With Me," "Everyone I Love Is Dead," and "All Hallows Eve" epitomize the bleakest aspects of goth — as did the unexpected death last year of its social-outcast singer, Peter Steele.

Their frontman is running around in sleeveless shirts and bright red hair these days, but in the early 2000s My Chemical Romance were straight goth for the emo generation who had taken on their predecessors' mantle of the outcast. MCR eventually turned to cheap theatrics for The Black Parade (2006). And if being known by the company you keep is true, Finnish "love rock" act H.I.M. don't have a chance at keeping up the goth ruse by kicking around with the crew from Jackass. But the broken-soul style of singer Ville Valo is defined by shade, damaged hearts, and that utterly goth-tastic heartagram logo.

  Topics: Music Features , My Chemical Romance
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 12/27 ]   Peter Pan  @ City Hall Plaza
[ 12/27 ]   Andy Goldsworthy: "Snow"  @ DeCordova Sculpture Park and Museum
[ 12/27 ]   Juan Jose Barboza-Gubo: "Cruor - Proelium - Cervus"  @ Fourth Wall Project
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   THE DØ | BOTH WAYS OPEN JAWS  |  December 14, 2011
    For people put off by the epic grandeur of Björk's recent Biophilia multimedia spectacle and longing for the song structures of Post and Homogenic , Both Ways Open Jaws will more than suffice.
  •   GETTING ROCKED WITH COCKED N' LOADED  |  December 14, 2011
    Two years ago, Cocked N' Loaded opened for the rabble-rousing Upper Crust at the now-defunct Harpers Ferry in Allston.  
    It's a Saturday afternoon in Jamaica Plain and Greg Luttrell is sipping a house special at Canary Square.
  •   CHRIS CORNELL | SONGBOOK  |  December 06, 2011
    Chris Cornell's reaction to the critical lynching his Timbaland-produced debacle Scream took in 2009 was to grow his hair back out, reunite with Soundgarden (currently in the studio), and embark on a solo tour stripped down to just an acoustic guitar.
  •   THE BLACK KEYS | EL CAMINO  |  November 29, 2011
    El Camino has the unenviable task of following up last year's Brothers, but instead of trying to outdo its acclaimed predecessor, it scales things back and cranks up the volume.

 See all articles by: MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed