Venice was the right place at the right time. Not the city — which we were dining our way through at this time last year — but rather the Westerly restaurant. Driving through a cold and rainy South County, we were beckoned by a place that beckons like it was a campfire in the winter woods.
The semiformal atmosphere strikes an inviting balance between comfort and indulgence. The waitstaff wear ties and black aprons; a stuccoed partition next to our table was topped with plants; paintings were mostly picturesque scenes of Venice.
Despite the name, the restaurant doesn’t offer Venetian specialties — there isn’t even prosecco among the bubblies on the lengthy list of 80 or so wines, 17 by the glass. Menu offerings are as all over the map of Italy, just as the wine list is all over the globe. Under “Pesce e Crostaceo,” you can have tuna or swordfish prepared Sicilian style, the former with a kalamata olive, pine nut, and golden raisin caponata; the latter with a salmoriglio sauce, featuring olive oil and balsamic vinegar ($19 and $18). Northern Italian recipes are represented by such lighter preparations as veal or chicken piccata ($16-$18).
The heart of this kitchen is in the South, tipped off by the antipasto ($9) containing meatballs and the locally appreciated “soupy,” dried sausage. A recent six-course meal at Venice was billed as “A Tour of Southern Italy.” The only soup permanently on the menu is pasta e fagioli ($3-$4). It’s a sort of pan-Italian pasta-and-bean soup, with distinct variations in regions from Tuscany to Sicily, but is known in the US as pasta fazool, as it is called in Naples. This restaurant has a good recipe, sticking to tradition by using tubettini pasta but venturing to include great northerns instead of the similar cannelloni beans, an incremental flavor boost.
We’ve also had their mussels zuppa ($7), which were fat, fresh, and swimming in plenty of garlicky white wine sauce to dip bread into. But this time I tried their grilled portobello ($7) for an appetizer, a good choice. The saucer-size cap was topped with green peas, bits of the shrimp, spinach, and — odd choice — Swiss cheese, full of flavors. The presentation was elegant: surrounded by a confetti of vari-colored bell pepper bits and ground black pepper, in a pool of tasty pink brandy cream sauce. Johnnie was up for the Boston bibb salad ($7), which was chock full of crumbled Gorgonzola, candied walnuts, and sun-dried tomatoes, tossed with a not-too-tart balsamic vinaigrette that she loved.
Herb-infused olive oil is on the table, as well as softened butter in a little bowl next to the breadbasket. It’s good to have your health provided for unasked. Perusing the pastas, I noticed that they still had a dish appreciated during our last visit. The scallops alla vodka ($18) had impressed me with a touch of smokiness in the sauce as well as the freshness of the scallops. The seafood fra diavola ($18) was especially tempting this time, since I knew the restaurant would be generous with the shrimp, scallops, calamari, and littlenecks. The linguine with clams ($17) also looked appealing, because there were littlenecks and chopped clams, plus a double bonus of Italian sausage and arugula.
But after indulging so much with our trio of starters, I wanted something lighter. What fit the bill perfectly was the butternut squash ravioli ($16). Nearly a dozen ravioli were tossed with generous amounts of pancetta and toasted pine nuts, with fresh spinach providing both color and flavor. Also plentiful, as well is delicious, was the sage cream sauce. The sweetness of the filling was complemented beautifully by the other contrasting tastes.
We had enjoyed swordfish here before, but this time instead of having it with a puttanesca sauce, Johnnie wanted to try the above-mentioned swordfish salmoriglio ($18). As well as being fresh and flavorfully grilled, it was finished with olive oil and balsamic vinegar. I found more flavor in the chopped tomatoes topping than did Johnnie, tastes of August bounty still echoing in her recollection. I did agree with her, though, that the asparagus spears were too thin to be so severely grilled — they were blackened and dried out. The pilaf, however, had a nice textural contrast of long-grain white with lots of crunchy wild rice.
They have a nicely balanced tiramisu here, which is kitchen-made along with their lemon cheesecake. Other desserts include cannoli, carrot cake, and chocolate cakes.
You can’t take a gondola ride to get to this restaurant, but since it is affiliated with the Winnapaug Inn next door, you know it’s going to be open for dinner storm or sunshine, seven days a week. Just like mama’s kitchen.
Venice Restaurant | 165 Shore Road, Westerly | Open daily, 4-10 pm | Major credit cards | Full bar | Sidewalk-level access | 401.348.0055
Email the author:
Bill Rodriguez: firstname.lastname@example.org