The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
CD Reviews  |  Classical  |  Live Reviews  |  Music Features

Oedipus schmoedipus

By LLOYD SCHWARTZ  |  January 21, 2011

Given the stirring semi-staged concert version that Federico Cortese led of Macbeth, the most fulfilled of Verdi's early operas, and the demise of the New England String Orchestra, which he'd been directing, I'd love to see him reinvent the old Boston Concert Opera and give us a regular series of musically distinguished versions of operas unlikely to be staged by our leading opera companies. He drew exceptional performances from the Boston Youth Symphony Orchestra, Holly MacEwen Krafka's New World Chorale (singing witches, assassins, and Scottish patriots up in the Sanders Theatre balcony), and a strong cast. Sturdy yet sympathetic Met and NYC Opera baritone Louis Otey sang the taxing title role (he had to recharge his battery before the final act, and did), but tenors Brian Landry and Steven Sanders nearly stole the show as Macduff and Malcolm. Lady Macbeth was the essentially miscast soprano Diana Jacklin, who had a large-scale and pretty upper register (which made, thank goodness, for a touching "Sleepwalking Scene") but few of the part's crucial low notes, an uncomfortable register break, little of the "ugly" vocal grit or biting diction Verdi wanted, and a crude projection of character.

Marc Verzatt's skillful stage direction kept most of the action simple, and he had at least one brilliant idea. One of the sillier aspects of Macbeth is Verdi's chorus of witches. But here, while the chorus sang, three dancers reeling and writhing in black and red gave us plenty of toil and trouble. The lead witch was none other than fondly remembered former Boston Ballet prima ballerina Laura Young. This event kicked off the 150th anniversary of Italian reunification.

Neither a bad cold nor last-minute changes of accompanist and program could prevent soprano Christine Brewer's Boston recital debut (Celebrity Series of Boston) from being a thoroughly enjoyable and satisfying concert. Brewer obviously has technique to burn — a blazing, clarion voice that she can also scale down to tender intimacy, with commendable diction — along with both stylistic variety and conviction. She can even whistle!

She and pianist Craig Terry got off to a rough, heavyhanded start in Alceste's heroic confrontation with the Underworld in Glück's "Divinités du Styx," but they warmed up during Wagner's Wesendonck Lieder and three big Richard Strauss songs, and they really started to cook in Benjamin Britten's sexy and witty Cabaret Songs (lyrics by Auden including the chilling "Funeral Blues" recited in Four Weddings and a Funeral). The program ended with John Carter's Cantata (a cycle of spirituals) and a fragrant bouquet of old-fashioned diva encores (like Idabelle Firestone's "If I Could Tell You," theme song of radio and TV's Voice of Firestone). Brewer struck her deepest emotional chord in her most lightweight number, her encore: "Mira," from Carnival, Bob Merrill's Broadway musical based on the film Lili. "Can you imagine that! Can you imagine that! Everybody knew my name!"

< prev  1  |  2  |  3  | 
Related: Fall Classical Preview: The power of music, Review: Jonathan McPhee & the Longwood Symphony Orchestra at Jordan Hall, Resurrections, More more >
  Topics: Classical , Opera, James Levine, Boston Symphony Orchestra,  More more >
| More
Add Comment
HTML Prohibited

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 10/11 ]   Deadmau5  @ House of Blues
[ 10/11 ]   The Rosebuds + Mount Moriah  @ Brighton Music Hall
Share this entry with Delicious
    The season-opening concerts I've been going to have made me think about two kinds of musicians: those whose performances become transparent, who allow the listener into the heart of the music; and those for whom their own abilities — technical marvels — seem an end, not a means to a higher end.
    How could a musical with a dazzling score and a perfect cast have been such a dismal flop on Broadway?
  •   GUERILLA OPERA'S LOOSE, WET, PERFORATED  |  September 20, 2011
    Australian born, Harvard-educated Nicholas Vines is a compellingly original composer, and his new Loose, Wet, Perforated (through September 25) is full of fascinating music.
  •   THE 10 CAN’T-MISS CLASSICAL CONCERTS OF 2011  |  October 03, 2011
    Here are 10 classical events I'm particularly eager to hear--just the tips of our many musical icebergs.
    This year Drew Minter and BMO gave us the young Rossini's The Italian Girl in Algiers , composed when he was 21 (it was his 11th opera!). It's an energetic comedy about a wily young woman who outwits the warlord who wants to add her to his harem.

 See all articles by: LLOYD SCHWARTZ

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed