LISTINGS |  EDITOR'S PICKS |  NEWS |  MUSIC |  MOVIES |  DINING |  LIFE |  ARTS |  REC ROOM |  THE BEST |  CLASSIFIED

Hot topic

Chill out, global warming is a lie
August 22, 2007 4:55:09 PM

070824_jacoby_main

In the August 19 Boston Globe, conservative op-ed contributor Jeff Jacoby wrote his fifth column in eight months denying climate change. His disdain for warming theorists goes back much longer; he pontificated on the subject as far back as 2002. And yet, after all this time and effort, he’s still relying on thin gruel for source material.

Jacoby’s most recent evidence against the global-warming consensus consists of:

• The Fred Singer petition — signed mostly by retired or non-practicing scientists, and some non-scientists — which merely questions whether the reality of climate change will be as horrific as the models currently predict.

• NASA administrator (since 2005) — and non-climatologist — Michael Griffin’s one-time comment that we shouldn’t worry about global warming, for which Griffin was denounced by NASA’s top climate official.

• One survey, conducted in 2003, purporting to show skepticism among environmental scientists, which was rejected for publication and generally discredited because its Web-based survey mechanism did not verify that the participants were actual scientists. (Interestingly, Jacoby cites the survey’s finding that 34 percent responded global warming might prove beneficial for some societies. This is actually a surprisingly low number, taken by some as evidence that non-experts took the survey: most serious climatologists agree, for example, that large sections of Russia are likely to benefit significantly from global warming, at least in the near-term.)

If Jacoby is going to keep at this topic, he needs to do so in a serious manner, not by citing the rare outlier. He needs to change course and stop citing evidence based on conflicting opinions. He needs to start presenting an argument for why we should listen to dissenters, rather than the overwhelming majority of people who have studied the issue.

Surely, if nine oncologists tell Jacoby that he needs a growth removed, and one tells him that the evidence of malignancy was not as strong as the others suggest, he would demand a strong argument for listening to the one over the nine. And he would demand better than what he is offering for why we should ignore calls for action on climate change.

COMMENTS

Nice retort. It doesn't take much to rebut the likes of Jacoby.... but it's still necessary. Jacoby has yet to figure out the difference between scientific evidence and opinion. I know a lot of scientists who question the validity of evolutionary theory - however, unless they can prove otherwise using researched evidence, they're thoughts are just that, thoughts or opinion. Anyways, nice column, I re-posted on a site I manage: //www.desmogblog.com/jacobys-questionable-column-is-chopped-liver

POSTED BY Kevin@desmogblog.com AT 08/27/07 1:25 PM
These "Global Warming Doesn't Exist" types are all misguided, plain and simple. Whether or not we've irrevocably hurt planetary ecology doesn't alter the fact that we have an obscenely wasteful and toxic culture of over-consumption. We should be laboring mightily to reduce pollution and emissions and erosion and overdevelopment -- and foster environmentally sustainable economies -- because it's sound, rational thinking. The (increasingly dubious) view that the planet can handle our bad behavior doesn't make our behavior any more acceptable. Far as I can tell, these "Global Warming Doesn't Exist" types are simply arguing from a perspective of greed and irresponsibility. Unfettered pollution is, in the short term at least, nicely profitable for the energy-hogging robber-barons that prop up their portfolios. Anybody seriously think it's anything but that? -- mattmchugh.com

POSTED BY mattmchugh.com AT 08/31/07 3:26 PM

Login to add comments to this article
Email

Password




Register Now  |   Lost password

MOST POPULAR

ADVERTISEMENT

BY THIS AUTHOR

PHOENIX MEDIA GROUP
CLASSIFIEDS







TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
   
Copyright © 2007 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group