Not so great

San Francisco's Nutcracker on PBS
By JEFFREY GANTZ  |  December 2, 2008

SWEET AND CHILDREN-FRIENDLY: But this San Francisco Nutcracker should be more.

Way back in 1977, PBS's Great Performances: Dance in America series and American Ballet Theatre gave us a Nutcracker with a difference: Mikhail Baryshnikov as an electrifying Nutcracker/Cavalier and willowy Gelsey Kirkland as an older-than-usual Clara who in her second-act dream became the Sugar Plum Fairy and danced in romantic ecstasy with her hero. It all dissolved in that confusing way dreams do, and what was one to think at the end, when Kirkland, awake and back home, pressed her nose to the window and watched the snow fall? But the production was a brave attempt to make Tchaikovsky's 1893 ballet the hard nut that it sometimes is in the original story (German Romantic E.T.A. Hoffmann's 1816 novella) as well as a holiday bonbon.

Television and film have brought us few such efforts since. Carroll Ballard's 1986 Nutcracker: The Motion Picture had Pacific Northwest Ballet dancing to sets by Maurice Sendak, but they hardly registered on screen. Mark Morris's The Hard Nut (!), for PBS in 1993, spoofed '50s and '60s America and threw in a sly pas deux for Droßelmeier and his Nutcracker nephew. (Tchaikovsky at the end of his life was besotted with his nephew.) That same year, the holiday film George Balanchine's The Nutcracker freighted Darci Kistler and Damian Woetzel and the rest of New York City Ballet with a wooden Macaulay Culkin as Droßelmeier's nephew.

This year, PBS is bringing us the new San Francisco Ballet Nutcracker (airs on WGBH a week from Wednesday, December 17, at 8 pm). The conceit is that the production is set during the Panama-Pacific International Exposition of 1915, a world's fair in which San Francisco heralded its triumphant recovery from the devastating 1906 earthquake. The TV presentation is hosted by Olympic figure-skating gold medalist and Dancing with the Stars idol Kristi Yamaguchi, who recalls how her mother took her to the San Francisco Ballet Nutcracker when she was a little girl. At the end of the show, there's a short segment on the Exposition, whose Palace of Horticulture had a dome bigger than St. Peter's. The tinted postcards make it all look fabulous; you wish you could go.

If only this Nutcracker were as enticing. It's similar to Boston Ballet's (BB artistic director Mikko Nissinen was a principal dancer at SFB for nine years), and most of the comparisons go in Boston Ballet's favor. The San Francisco Droßelmeiers live in a Victorian with a big curving staircase, and yes, it's great to see Fritz slide down the banister. But the production is sweet and bland and children-friendly to a fault (pretty much what Yamaguchi advertised), and most of the principal dancing — Snow King (Pierre-François Vilanoba) and Queen (Yuan Yuan Tan), "Sugar Plum" (Vanessa Zahorian, actually dancing the Waltz of the Flowers), "Adult Clara" (Maria Kochetkova) and her Nutcracker (Davit Karapetyan) — is skating-exhibition level. For the second act, Yamaguchi promises a surprise: Clara will dance with her Nutcracker Prince. That sounds like good news: the beaming, mischievous Elizabeth Powell has been the best thing about the ballet. But then we get her "adult version" in Kochetkova, who's far from "dazzling" (as the SFB publicity blurb describes her). The most exciting dancing comes from Karapetyan, who combines ballon with bravura; Boston Ballet would be lucky to have him.

1  |  2  |   next >
  Topics: Dance , Politics, Entertainment, San Francisco Ballet,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   HANDEL AND HAYDN'S PURCELL  |  February 04, 2013
    Set, rather confusingly, in Mexico and Peru, the 1695 semi-opera The Indian Queen is as contorted in its plot as any real opera.
  •   REVIEW: MAHLER ON THE COUCH  |  November 27, 2012
    Mahler on the Couch , from the father-and-son directing team of Percy and Felix Adlon, offers some creative speculation, with flashbacks detailing the crisis points of the marriage and snatches from the anguished first movement of Mahler's unfinished Tenth Symphony.
    "Without The Nutcracker , there'd be no ballet in America as we know it."
    War Horse's puppet Joey, all chestnut mesh and cane and repurposed bicycle parts, could become America's biggest equine sensation since Secretariat.
    The man of the hour is running for high office, and he has the support of the party faithful and the moneyed interests, but before he can claim victory, he must ingratiate himself with the unwashed masses, even as rival interests conspire to blacken his name and deprive him of all popular appeal.

 See all articles by: JEFFREY GANTZ