The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
Media -- Dont Quote Me  |  News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In

Righting a staggering wrong

It is time for the US Attorney to investigate how and why the Boston police wrongfully convicted Stephan Cowans
By EDITORIAL  |  February 6, 2008


Framed? The Boston Police investigation of Stephan Cowans led to a wrongful conviction. Was it incompetent — or corrupt? By David S. Bernstein
If US Attorney Michael J. Sullivan cares about the quality of justice in Boston and the performance of the troubled Boston Police Department (BPD), he will launch an investigation into how that department managed to help convict the wrong man — Stephan Cowans — in the 1997 shooting of a Boston cop. As a result of either staggeringly poor police work or serious wrongdoing, Cowans spent six-and-a-half years in prison. State and county officials have proven that they did not — and still do not — have the guts or the wit to do the job of policing the police.

Not quite four years ago, announcing the end of the probe into Cowans’s wrongful conviction, then–attorney general Thomas Reilly said that “we used every tool at our disposal,” but could not bring any criminal charges against the officers responsible.

Anyone who reads the exclusive report by David S. Bernstein will find that conclusion a hard pill to swallow. The possibility of serious police misconduct is too strong to ignore.

The US Attorney’s Office has the tools for the job, including the ability to levy conspiracy- and public-corruption charges. Sullivan may also be far enough removed from the city police and prosecutors to tackle the case aggressively, and to answer the difficult and uncomfortable questions that beg resolution.

There are clear, compelling reasons to clarify the miscarriage of justice that the Cowans case represents.

Any cops, retired or active, found to have deliberately subverted justice should be called to account. Any of those still on the force who are found to be incompetent need oversight and training. A real cop shooter remains unidentified.

A US Justice Department investigation could bring a cleansing light to bear on the BPD, and might very well lead to reforms that, for a variety of reasons — some valid, others bogus — local political leaders have been unable or unwilling to enact.

But there is an even greater reason to investigate the Cowans case: the sense of trust and community that normally holds a city together is obviously unraveling in Boston’s streets.

Quite simply, we need to trust our cops. And to do that, we need to know that someone will hold cops responsible if they abuse their badges.

Our officials have chosen to bury their heads in the sand. Five years ago, they received an unmistakable warning, a red flag they chose to ignore and deny. In 2003, the city’s biannual survey of residents’ attitudes toward the police revealed a sharp drop in citywide confidence. That lack of confidence was clear in white neighborhoods, but it was felt most acutely among African-American Bostonians. Rather than act on the report’s findings, Mayor Thomas Menino chose to aggressively discount them. When the Phoenix obtained and reported the results, Menino and then–police commissioner Kathleen O’Toole criticized the survey, and decided never to conduct it again, dismantling one of the city’s early-warning systems that measures public confidence in the police.

1  |  2  |   next >
Related: Framed?, Boston agrees to pay $3.2 million to Stephan Cowans, Truth, Justice — or the Boston Way, More more >
  Topics: The Editorial Page , Politics, Criminal Sentencing and Punishment, Tom Menino,  More more >
  • Share:
  • Share this entry with Facebook
  • Share this entry with Digg
  • Share this entry with Delicious
  • RSS feed
  • Email this article to a friend
  • Print this article
Righting a staggering wrong
While asking the U.S. Attorney to investigate local misconduct is usually a reasonable request, please know that the U.S. Attorney's office has failed, so far, to examine two wrongful convictions prosecuted by its own Assistant U.S. Attorneys. Alfred Trenkler and Tom Shay were wrongly convicted in Boston Federal Court in 1993 of building a bomb that killed Boston Bomb Squad officer Jeremiah Hurley and maimed his partner, Francis Foley. Both Trenkler and Shay are "perfectly innocent" which is the name of the book about the case, posted at the website The Boston Police Dept. was pursuing the reasonable leads in the case, but they turned the case over to the U.S. Attorney's office and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF). Alfred Trenkler and Tom Shay barely knew each other and Alfred didn't even know about the lawsuit that Tom's father was pursuing and from which the U.S. Attorney's office claimed Tom wanted to inherit a share. Given Alfred's private school background, the money motive was absurd. The claimed friendship was barely an acquaintance, as Alfred Trenkler had been with Tom Shay a total of only a few hours during hitchhiked rides, and their last contact was two months before the October 1991 Roslindale Bomb explosion. Alfred is now pursuing a habeas corpus claim in Federal Court, and has learned that the ATF had destroyed the evidence that we believe had DNA in it. This past week, Alfred Trenkler was transferred to the Federal Prison in Devens, Mass after being out-of-sight, out-of-mind for 15 years in prison in Pennsylvania. A copy of the manuscript for the book, "Perfectly Innocent" has been sent to U.S. Attorney Michael J. Sullivan and to his predecessors who prosecuted the Roslindale Bomb case, but none has responded with any comments, corrections or criticisms. Without corrections of errors, the book's conclusion of wrongful conviction stands. Mr. Sullivan was asked to investigate the Roslindale case and see for himself how two wrongful convictions occurred. Quoted in that request was Suffolk County Dan Conley's powerful statement about prosecutors and justice: "I believe that the act of freeing one innocent person wrongly imprisoned is profoundly more important than all the criminals we arrest, prosecute, and convict." Not only are Alfred Trenkler and Tom Shay innocenct, but the real builder of the Roslindale Bomb is free. Also, Jeremiah Hurley's family and Francis Foley and his family, must continually be dragged through this tragic story because there can be no closure for them when innocent men have been wrongly convicted. Morrison Bonpasse
By morrisonbonpasse on 02/11/2008 at 9:10:21

Share this entry with Delicious
  •   DISCLOSURE: NOT A DIRTY WORD  |  September 30, 2009
    The City Hall e-mail scandal that has scored headlines in recent weeks exemplifies Mayor Thomas Menino's antagonistic — almost contemptuous — attitude toward public accountability.
  •   CAN BEACON HILL DO BETTER?  |  September 23, 2009
    With DiMasi gone, the idea of casino gambling is again alive.
  •   VOTE YOON  |  September 17, 2009
    Barring supernatural intervention next Tuesday, incumbent Thomas Menino is expected to top the ticket in Boston's four-candidate mayoral preliminary. The final vote will take place November 3.
  •   MERCHANTS OF DEATH  |  September 09, 2009
    Wall Street has found a new way to make a buck: buy up the life-insurance policies of the sick and the aged at a fraction of their cost, bundle them into bonds that will be sold to investors, and profit from them when the policy holders die sooner rather than later.
  •   CHOOSING KENNEDY’S SUCCESSOR  |  September 02, 2009
    Massachusetts should have a temporary US senator until voters elect a replacement to serve out the remaining three years of Ted Kennedy’s term.

 See all articles by: EDITORIAL

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2009 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group