CD Reviews

Erin McKeown

Sing You Sinners | Nettwerk

By TED DROZDOWSKI | January 16, 2007

With Madeleine Peyroux and Norah Jones as ingrained in the cultural fabric as cockroaches in an Allston student flat, there isn’t much refreshing about yet another pop singer’s taking a whack at a few pages in the Great American Songbook. In fact, on the heels of Peyroux’s cash-in on the Starbuck’s easy-listening set, McKeown’s Sing You Sinners seems like just another sop. But in the four-page softball interview that serves as the CD’s liner notes, the indie singer-songwriter assures us it’s not. And at times she and her band sound inspired, as when she tears off a jazzy little guitar solo in the title track, or when her group’s calypso shuffle arrangement of “Paper Moon” — driven by this disc’s secret musical star, drummer Allison Miller — provides a shot of vitamin B. Dipped in several coats of playful irony, McKeown’s own “Melody,” matches the spirit of the numbers written by the likes of Harold Arlen, Cole Porter, and Johnny Mercer, and Fats Waller’s weedy “If You a Viper” is a welcome surprise. But these tracks suffer from an overriding sameness, with McKeown playing her voice as a trump card. Her singing is pretty and crisp, but the limitations of her range are obvious when she flexes hard, and more so against the backdrop of this repertoire’s history. Precious and uninteresting as it may be, Sing Your Sinners will probably bring her to a new mocha-latte-loving audience.

Indie springs forward
Clap your hands and say Axl
Madeleine Peyroux
Half The Perfect World | Rounder
Erin McKeown: Lafayette
Signature Sounds
More

Topics: CD Reviews , Erin McKeown , Madeleine Peyroux , Norah Jones , More

Comments

Add a Comment

ARTICLES BY TED DROZDOWSKI

ANI DIFRANCO | RED LETTER YEAR | September 23, 2008
Righteous Babe (2008)

MIX NUTS | September 23, 2008
An interview with breakout roots-music production stars the Tremolo Twins

INTERVIEW: DICK SMOTHERS | September 17, 2008
Mom always liked him best

B.B. KING | September 10, 2008
One Kind Favor | Geffen

BASIC ELEMENTS | September 08, 2008
The international and roots-music scene heats up

See all articles by: TED DROZDOWSKI

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

LONG NATIONAL NIGHTMARE
What if all the pundits, pollsters, and press are (gasp!) wrong about Obama’s chances?

DIANNE'S SPECIAL DEAL
State Senator Dianne Wilkerson already has amassed a list of embarrassing political pratfalls. The Phoenix uncovers two more situations that should cause concern on the cusp of the election.

DICTATOR MCCAIN?
Don’t laugh: if the Arizona ‘maverick’ is elected, he’ll complete the job Bush started

TRAVELS WITH SARAH
As Palin tours New Hampshire, signs of Biblical calling, talent on the stump, and a shot at 2012

BACK BEAT
At last, Kerouac and Burroughs's co-authored noir novel, And the Hippos Were Boiled in Their Tanks, resurfaces.

LONG NATIONAL NIGHTMARE
What if all the pundits, pollsters, and press are (gasp!) wrong about Obama’s chances?

DIANNE'S SPECIAL DEAL
State Senator Dianne Wilkerson already has amassed a list of embarrassing political pratfalls. The Phoenix uncovers two more situations that should cause concern on the cusp of the election.

TRAVELS WITH SARAH
As Palin tours New Hampshire, signs of Biblical calling, talent on the stump, and a shot at 2012

BACK BEAT
At last, Kerouac and Burroughs's co-authored noir novel, And the Hippos Were Boiled in Their Tanks, resurfaces.

ON THE MOVE
Andrew Neumann at the Axiom Center, Cristina Toro at LaMontagne Gallery, Taylor Davis at Samson Projects

HOT TOPICS

Boston Symphony Orchestra , Kim Deal , Radiohead , Massachusetts Institute of Technology , Harvard University , Kurt Weill , James Levine , James Robinson , John Harbison , Brian Eno

CD Reviews

Erin McKeown

Back Beat

Scarlet letters

Interview: John Hodgman

Pilgrims’ progress

Ghost writer