LISTINGS |  EDITOR'S PICKS | NEWS | MUSIC | MOVIES | DINING | LIFE | ARTS | REC ROOM | CLASSIFIEDS | VIDEO

Defending the universally loathed

January 14, 2008 9:56:06 AM

pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

080111_scrooge_

Fictional Character: Scrooge
Is there a more despised character in literature than Dickens’s Ebenezer Scrooge? His name itself has become a generic term for a miser — some uncharitable, unfeeling, unloved, greedy disbeliever in the spirit of giving others a helping hand. By the end of A Christmas Carol, of course, he “sees the light,” but the kindly old geezer he turns into — who buys a turkey for the Cratchit family — is not, of course, what we think of when we hear “Scrooge.”

But here’s the Scrooge you don’t know. A neglected, misunderstood child; crossed in love as a young man, he turns inward. He’s quite honest about his feelings: all he wants is to leave his memories behind, and not be bothered by people, but they won’t let him alone. His only salvation is his work, and he works hard; yet he’s besieged by fundraisers, and tortured — literally tortured — by having ghosts rub his face in his painful past. Imagine someone Jewish or Muslim or gay, an atheist, an intellectual, a music critic — anyone surrounded by and forced to submit to cultural norms he or she doesn’t like, or fit, coerced into celebrating someone else’s holiday.

I think Dickens half understands this. He gives Scrooge a reason to turn his back on frivolity. But he also stacks the deck against him, and makes him suffer terribly for what he can’t help but feel. Turns out he’s really pretty lovable underneath — what choice does he have? Scrooge’s best revenge, though, is that he’s the most compelling character in the book, one of the best characters in all of Dickens. Is anyone really interested in Bob Cratchit or, heaven help us, Tiny Tim? Whom do we really care about — or, yes, identify with — in the book, or any of its media incarnations? He’s Dickens’s unintentionally modern hero.

— Lloyd Schwartz

loathed_qvc

TV: Shopping channels
As detestable as they are, someone loves those shopping channels on TV. They bring in more than $10 billion a year to the washed-up non-celebrities pitching second-rate knives, dresses, jewelry, and cleaning supplies.

There is, however, a very compelling reason you, too, should love the shopping channels, and thank your lucky stars they exist: your cable bill would be higher than it is now — by as much as a few bucks a month, depending on where you live — if the “basic cable” package did not include shopping channels.

In many markets, cable companies are required by federal regulations to carry shopping channels. As a result, the cable companies don’t pay to transmit shopping channels (just as they don’t pay to carry other local broadcast stations or community-access channels). But unlike those other channels, shopping networks kick back a percentage of their sales revenues. So the more knives sold, the less likely your cable bill is to rise.

(Sure, nothing is stopping your cable company from racking the rates, except competition from satellite TV and Internet video, but if the feds require cable companies to sell channels individually, you’ll pay more for the same channels, and losing that shopping-network revenue is part of why.)

So every now and again, when you’re feeling bored, check out a shopping channel, and make sure you have a knife for every occasion. If you’re missing one for, say, cutting out your own appendix, go ahead and buy it. It’s just $9.99, you can pay in 15 easy installments of just 67 cents each, and you’ll keep your future cable bills down, too.

— Jeff Inglis

green

Comedian: Tom Green
Does Tom Green look back on his relationship with Drew Barrymore and wonder whether it was all a dream? Look at the dude: a squirrel-faced spaz from the wilds of white-bread Ottawa. A guy who humps dead moose and whose best friend is named Glenn Humplik has no business canoodling with The Wedding Singer’s Julia Gulia. Surely, such an unholy union could not last. (It didn’t.) But the amazing thing is that he dumped her. Green (if you believe Wikipedia) was bugged by Barrymore’s “increasingly neurotic behavior.” That’s rich. He’s also said to have been peeved that, at their wedding, most of her showbiz friends “paid no attention to Green’s own friends and family, since they ‘weren’t famous.’ ”

Green has never pretended to be something he’s not. Of course, millions upon millions have decided that what he is — puerile, scatological, deranged — is excruciatingly irritating. But if one of Green’s virtues is loyalty to his humble roots, another is his unappreciated knack for a slyly intellectual strain of comedy that has a whiff of Duchamp about it. Yes, really. Johnny Knoxville may have stolen Green’s conceit of fucking with sympathetic, unsuspecting passersby — feigning horrific disability, placing a baby doll atop a moving car — but did anyone from Jackass ever think to hang their own painting on the walls of the National Gallery of Canada? (Green’s hung there unmolested for several days.)

Performing frottage with deceased woodland beasts doesn’t require much imagination. Nor does slurping from a cow’s teat. But if the “Bum Bum Song” was the nadir of Western civilization, Freddie Got Fingered — as Roger Ebert wrote in his zero-star review — may one day be appreciated as a “milestone of neo-surrealism.” It takes a fearless artist to airbrush a graphic tableau of lesbian cunnilingus on the hood of your buttoned-down dad’s company car. It takes a fearless man to laugh in cancer’s face, poking at his excised and dissected testicle and saying, “looks like chicken.”

— Mike Miliard


pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6
COMMENTS

The French make the best french fries known to man, not to mention the best french toast. And who can French-kiss like a French woman?

POSTED BY gordon AT 01/12/08 6:33 AM
I agree that criticism is a consumer convenience. In addition it is usually well written and interesting. That said, true evaluation only obtains between artist and audience. Yale Scholar RWB Lewis said, "Critics don't make canons, writers make canons."

POSTED BY gordon AT 01/12/08 6:44 AM
In other words, Silber has half a brain, and he's dangerous.

POSTED BY gordon AT 01/12/08 6:54 AM
In other words, Silber has half a brain, and he's dangerous.

POSTED BY gordon AT 01/12/08 6:54 AM
In other words, Silber has half a brain, and he's dangerous.

POSTED BY gordon AT 01/12/08 6:55 AM
I am glad to read Sharon Steel is proud to admit she's devoted to Ashlee Simpson, even if she does find it inexplainable. My devotion to Ashlee is something I CAN explain. And it goes beyond my being an against-the-grainer, a defender of lost causes, a forgiver of miss-takes, a male-feminist fighter against misogyny, an old hippie/punk power popper. Ashlee has tall talent & that's no lie. She has a deep, sexy joyous voice. Her mad music is what matters most & it moves me so. She can break my heart, show it to me & put it back together again. She is the laughing girl w/the most fun house. ..... From Ashes to Smashlee, Dust to Magic Star Dust, this Megatop Phoenix gonna rise above, like us she must. She can sing, she can dance, she can clown, she can bring it on w/everything & more till there's nothing left to lose out on the floor but herself in our l.o.v.e. for her.

POSTED BY thewaymouth AT 01/13/08 6:32 PM

Login to add comments to this article
Email

Password




Register Now  |   Lost password

MOST POPULAR

 VIEWED   EMAILED 

ADVERTISEMENT

BY THIS AUTHOR

PHOENIX MEDIA GROUP
CLASSIFIEDS







TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
   
Copyright © 2008 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group