The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures

Review: Not Fade Away

Fade to Black
By JAKE MULLIGAN  |  January 2, 2013
3.5 3.5 Stars

Can a movie be intimate and rock-and-roll at the same time? That's what Sopranos creator David Chase seems to be going for with his 1960s-set memoir Not Fade Away, which follows Douglas (John Magaro) and his crew of friends in their hopeless attempts to strike it big as a rock band. Groups like the Rolling Stones have made it possible for skinny white people to be "cool," and Doug — pining for a way to impress classmate Grace (the luminous Bella Heathcote) — sees in them his opportunity for fame. But this isn't a biopic; his skills aren't up to those of Mick and Keith.

>> READ: "David Chase's goodbye to TV" <<

And so years pass, marked not by title cards but by historical events — the Beatles and Stones on TV, the sexual revolution, the Vietnam War, taking a date to see Blow-Up at the local theater. As the crew members grow older, their hopes for fame grow slighter, and Fade becomes less about the music than about the people playing it.

Chase's directing (as anyone who's watched The Sopranos knows) apes Scorsese shamelessly: he employs jukebox-style soundtrack cuts and kinetic camerawork that glides along to them emphatically. But in spite of the rockin' needle drops, his main interest is in quietly criticizing his characters' brutish self-interest, looking at the way their focus lies more on the press conferences they'll hold after they're famous than on the music they're playing to get there. He locates the soul of the picture in James Gandolfini as Douglas's father, Pat, who mourns the loss of the greatest generation and constantly chides his son for his proto-hippie fashions.

Selfishness drives all, every relationship is corrupted, and it all builds to a devastating climax. But unfortunately, the complaints that accompanied TheSopranos' mysterious finale seem to have had an effect on Chase: Fade closes with a borderline-insulting denouement, skewing closer to a thesis statement than a conclusion. After watching two hours of effectively ambiguous filmmaking, it's deflating to be told — by one of the characters, no less — how to think about Chase's themes. Though no doubt meant as an audacious metatextual flourish, it comes off more glib than profound.

But even if he doesn't stick the landing, the picture captures our country with daring honesty. Our inability to communicate across generational lines, our self-righteous approach to art, our knee-jerk reactions to political hot-buttons, our obsession with celebrity — Chase's critical eye spares no one. This is his attempt to make the "Great American Film About Music." He almost succeeds.

Related: Review: Mafia II, Review: Dark Shadows, Boo-ya!, More more >
  Topics: Reviews , The Sopranos, James Gandolfini, Blow-Up,  More more >
| More

Share this entry with Delicious
  •   REVIEW: WEST OF MEMPHIS  |  March 12, 2013
    Amy Berg's documentary about the case illustrates countless failings of the American justice system.
  •   REVIEW: YOSSI  |  March 06, 2013
    A decade after Yossi & Jagger , filmmaker Eytan Fox returns to see how his character is getting on.
  •   REVIEW: NO  |  March 04, 2013
    Many say that political rhetoric in the mainstream media is dead. NO purports to perform the autopsy.
  •   REVIEW: PHANTOM  |  February 27, 2013
    Simultaneously bizarre and banal, director Todd Robinson's military procedural seems designed to please no one.
  •   REVIEW: THE SWEENEY  |  February 27, 2013
    No single subgenre is as tired as "loose-cannon cop breaks the rules to bring down a band of ruthless criminals."

 See all articles by: JAKE MULLIGAN

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2017 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group