The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures

Lynch sides with Bush in opposing shield law

Talking Politics
By IAN DONNIS  |  July 9, 2008

As he gears up for a gubernatorial run in 2010, Attorney General Patrick C. Lynch has assembled an eclectic and sometimes contrary portfolio of issue-related stances.

As I wrote earlier this year (see “Patrick Lynch goes for broke,” News, January 23), “The AG seemed a progressive champion — and he incurred the wrath of Roman Catholic Bishop Thomas Tobin — when he ruled that the marriages of same-sex couples who wed out-of-state should be recognized in Rhode Island (a week earlier, his sister, Pawtucket City Solicitor Margaret Lynch-Gadaleta, had married in Massachusetts her longtime partner).

“Yet civil libertarians were outraged when Lynch, backing Foreign Intelligence Surveillance amendments, recently supported the role of private telephone companies to help US intelligence agencies.”

Earlier this year, Lynch emerged as a strong supporter of Barack Obama. Yet he has now placed himself in the ironic position of sharing George W. Bush’s stance on an impor-tant issue affecting the press — and everyone’s right to know.

As Ed Fitzpatrick reported last week in the Providence Journal, “Lynch is refusing to support the Free Flow of Information Act, which would create a qualified federal shield law for reporters,” even though the bill is backed by 42 other attorneys general.

The legislation would make it more difficult for judges to compel reporters to identify confidential sources.

Fitzpatrick’s story noted that a bipartisan letter sent by 41 attorneys general (one wrote separately to endorse the bill) “said the act would bring federal law into line with the laws of 49 states, including Rhode Island. They noted reporter shield laws have been adopted, through legislation or judicial decision, in every state but Wyoming.”

In explaining the opposition of Lynch, who last month became president of the National Association of Attorneys General, spokesman Michael J. Healey cited the issue as being one of federal legislation and how Rhode Island prosecutors bring more cases before grand juries than their out-of-state counterparts.

“Our position has nothing to do with First Amendment issues,” Healey told Fitzpatrick. “It’s simply about the propriety of a state that relies on the grand jury as much as we do telling the federal government how they should conduct grand juries. Our rationale is more based on jurisdictional issues than on philosophical issues. To be clear, we absolutely respect the work of journalists and how vital they are to our society.”

With its lack of county-based district attorneys, Rhode Island is an anomaly, and it’s no surprise that Lynch would think first of jurisdictional issues and his constituency in law en-forcement.

 Ultimately, though, the ability of reporters to protect confidential sources is an issue that affects all Americans. This is a big concern in Rhode Island, where the press has his-torically played a leading role in helping to expose wrongdoing, and some sources will not come forward without a pledge of confidentiality.

The Judith Miller case showed how reporters claiming protection under a shield law are not always serving the public.

Ultimately, however — and I think Jim Taricani (who risked a prison sentence, rather than revealing a source), our late friend Jack White, and many of our colleagues would heartily agree — the ability to protect confidential sources is vital for the public interest.

Related: Patrick Lynch goes for broke, The 12th Annual Muzzle Awards, Will Caprio’s early ad spree work?, More more >
  Topics: Talking Politics , Barack Obama, Politics, Culture and Lifestyle,  More more >
| More

Share this entry with Delicious
    Five years ago, when Farm Fresh Rhode Island (FFRI) launched its mission of promoting Ocean State-produced food, co-founder Noah Fulmer discovered a curious disconnection in the local food chain.
  •   TICKET TO RIDE  |  February 11, 2009
    In April 1999, two weeks after I started on the job at the Providence Phoenix , the FBI raided City Hall, formally unveiling the federal investigation that would land Vincent A. "Buddy" Cianci Jr., Rhode Island's rascal king, behind bars.
    During a news conference Tuesday afternoon in the State House rotunda, proponents of significantly expanding publicly financed elections in Rhode Island — a concept they call "Fair Elections" — cited a litany of reasons for why it would be good for the Ocean State and its citizens.
  •   THE UPSIDE OF HOPE IN RHODE ISLAND  |  January 29, 2009
    Everywhere one turns these days, there's seemingly more bad news about Rhode Island: the unemployment rate, one of the highest in the nation, tops 10 percent — and the state's running out of unemployment assistance.
    Former Providence Journal reporter Jan Brogan is out with her fourth mystery, Teaser .

 See all articles by: IAN DONNIS

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2017 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group