Running as an independent, he could thumb his nose at the worst of both parties
By IAN DONNIS | April 10, 2008
 WELL-LIKED: Chafee, shown near his office at Brown, remains a very popular figure in Rhode Island. |
For now, Lincoln Chafee has the luxury of discussing his political future as a riddle wrapped up in an enigma.
While he says he loves teaching at Brown University’s Watson Institute — where he took up a post after losing his US Senate seat in 2006 — Chafee says the job is on a semester-by-semester basis, and he adds, “My own feeling is that my value here is what I bring from the outside, and that the longer I stay, the less value that I have.”
So, does that mean that the well-liked and quirky Republican-turned-independent, who has previously floated the possibility of running for governor, general treasurer, or mayor of Providence in 2010, is planning his return to politics? Is an ongoing burst of public appearances due just to the April 1 release of his new book, Againstthe Tide: How a Compliant Congress Empowered a Reckless President (St. Martin’s Books), or is it a taste of things to come?
Offering what has become something of a pro forma response, Chafee, 55, demurs when asked about his future, talking about how good it has been “to have a normal life again,” and how he’s at “a point in my life to make some good decisions.”
“I will say that I enjoy the challenges that elective office brings, and I am starting to think about it, and it is starting to loom on the horizon now,” Chafee adds during a recent interview, offering more of a nod to the real world of politics than when he called 2010 “a long way away” during an appearance on WJAR-TV’s 10 News Conference a few weeks ago. After doing whatever he can to help Barack Obama’s presidential campaign, the former senator says, he hopes to make some decisions at the end of this year.
Coming from most politicians, such hedging would seem suspect. Yet there’s little question that Chafee — to the delight of his admirers, and to the chagrin of his critics — marches to the beat of a different drummer. For a guy who spent years shoeing horses in Montana and Canada after his graduation from Brown in 1975, it wouldn’t be completely out of the question for him to take a walk.
Yet for connoisseurs of Rhode Island politics, the most tantalizing possibility would be an unprecedented three-way gubernatorial battle royal featuring a Democrat to be named later; Republican Stephen P. Laffey, Chafee’s hard-charging GOP primary opponent from 2006; and the independent Chafee, who embodies an appealing Ocean State tradition that blends liberalism, moderation, and fiscal conservatism.
With the state facing crushing budget deficits and continued partisan warfare between Republican Governor Donald L. Carcieri and the Democrat-controlled General Assembly, the grim fiscal outlook can be expected to persist through the next statewide election.
Considering this, the three-way gubernatorial scenario would offer a provocative choice to voters.
Laffey, who isn’t shy in describing his skill set as the answer for Rhode Island’s woes, would wield a sharply confrontational approach against legislative Democrats. A yet-to-be-determined number of Democratic candidates will tout an ability to get more done than the departing Carcieri. And Chafee — with a golden name and a credential as the only Senate Republican to vote against the war in Iraq — could offer both a collaborative approach and a demonstrated ability to go against the political grain.
Related:
Down to the wire, Advantage: Whitehouse, Rhode Island in ’06: same as it ever was, More
- Down to the wire
So will Cranston Mayor Stephen P. Laffey prove the ascending dragon-slayer who knocks off US Senator Lincoln Chafee, a favorite target of conservatives everywhere, or will the herky-jerky heir to one of the best brand names in Ocean State politics repel his challenger and live to fight another day?
- Advantage: Whitehouse
It was just one more in a steady stream of campaign stops, efforts that might land Sheldon Whitehouse six months from now in the most exclusive club in the nation.
- Rhode Island in ’06: same as it ever was
Imagine a year when the Narragansett Indians were energetically pitching a casino, cynical Rhode Islanders had plenty of reason to reinforce their jaundiced views, and state house Democrats maintained the upper hand over hapless Republican opponents without even breaking a sweat.
- Déjà vu all over again for RI GOP
Lincoln Chafee should be the next head of the Rhode Island Republican Party.
- Laffey attacks from the center
When Cranston Mayor Stephen P. Laffey announced last week that he didn’t even want the state Republican Party’s endorsement it marked a textbook move in the upstart’s stiff Republican primary challenge to US Senator Lincoln Chafee.
- Chafee emerges from geek status in TV debates with Laffey
Viewing the two recent televised debates between US Senator Lincoln Chafee and his GOP challenger, Cranston Mayor Stephen P. Laffey, was akin to taking a brisk 60-minute trip through psychiatrist Elizabeth Kubler-Ross’s five stages of grieving.
- Endorsements
The Republican primary for US Senate is, in many ways, a fight between the GOP of past and present.
- What’s next for Steve Laffey?
Can you imagine Steve Laffey — a tireless self-promoter and all-around media hog — not returning a phone call from a reporter?
- The Milquetoast and the Blowhard
Now is not the time for Lincoln Chafee to be timid.
- Aided by his name and the national GOP, Chafee beats back Laffey
Chafee attributed his 54-46 percent victory over Cranston Mayor Stephen P. Laffey to “a grassroots effort like Rhode Island has never seen.”
- Why RI Republicans fail
Providence Journal op-ed columnist Edward Achorn has made repeated reference to the apparent “learned helplessness” of Rhode Islanders.
- Less

Topics:
News Features
, Barack Obama, U.S. Government, Rhode Island AFL-CIO, More
, Barack Obama, U.S. Government, Rhode Island AFL-CIO, Dan Yorke, John Chafee, Bruce Sundlun, Frank Caprio, Lincoln Chafee, Darrell West, Matt Brown, Less