Reviews

Profit Motive and the Whispering Wind

A meditation on 400 years

By ROB NELSON | November 20, 2007

3.5 Stars

Ludlow massacre monument

Boston-based scholar and filmmaker John Gianvito’s minimalist ode to American activism is rare among lefty documentaries for allowing you to draw your own conclusions at your own pace. Indeed, the film is not so much entertainment or education as it is a meditation or a prayer. Lengthy, beautifully composed shots of gravestones and historical monuments (including many in Massachusetts) encourage us to mourn fallen heroes as well as to recognize our own vulnerability to larger forces — as represented in part by the corporate logos that sneak their way into Gianvito’s frame (as they do into most every other public space). Profit Motive is not for everyone. Inspired by the work of Howard Zinn, it spans some 400 years of history, subverting its genre’s obsession with topicality and reminding us that neither our nation’s injustice nor the struggle against it is remotely new. 57 minutes | MFA: November 29, 30; December 1, 8, 13

Related: Open city, A world of cinema, Mobilize against the war on Saturday, More

Topics: Reviews , Howard Zinn, John Gianvito

| More

See more deals

view all

[ 05/26 ] "A Natural Order," photographs by Lucas Foglia @ David Winton Bell Gallery

[ 05/26 ] George Orwell's 1984, adapted by Nick Lane @ Gamm Theatre

[ 05/26 ] "2012 RISD Graduate Thesis Exhibition" @ Rhode Island Convention Center

ARTICLES BY ROB NELSON

CONSTANTINE'S SWORD | May 28, 2008
Scarier than Jesus Camp (and infinitely smarter), Oren Jacoby’s documentary film of Boston Globe columnist James Carroll’s 2001 book Constantine’s Sword casts Christianity as a lost ark raided by the worst bullies of history.

SON OF RAMBOW | May 07, 2008
Funnier than anything in this vaguely dark comedy is the thought of Stallone sitting through it.

MY BLUEBERRY NIGHTS | April 16, 2008
Three years after 2046 , Wong Kar-wai is not in love any more — and I for one am happy for him. Perfectionism can be exhausting for all involved.

IRANIAN CHICK | January 10, 2008
At 38, Marjane Satrapi still resembles the kid in Persepolis , her autobiographical graphic-novel-turned-animated-film of growing up in Iran during the Islamic Revolution.